Don't look down. Hopefully, reverse psychology DID NOT KICK IN.
Before you read any further, and without looking down, answer this question. Who are three of the highly charismatic, personally dynamic leaders in the news today?
I'm sure you could identify one such person. How easy was it for you to come up with some more?
Here is a quote from Ira Chaleff in his book, the Courageous Follower that I came across in Leadership Divided.
Dynamic leaders are the spark, the flame that ignites action. With vision, they generate and focus power . . . In their passion, their expansiveness, their drive, dynamic leaders are prone to excess: a deal too large, a bottom line too important, a cause too righteous, an image too pure, a lifestyle too rich, an enemy too hated, a bridge too far.
Charisma has moved to the front burner once again, with Barak Obama's charisma a topic of conversastion in the news. A few days ago, I read a columnist (I forget her name) who was critical both of Obama's charisma and the celebritization of Obama.
One of the uneasy metaphors of leadership we have to deal with is the leader as hero. In the hero/leader, the dynamic and charismatic leader is admired as much for charisma as for accomplishment. The charismatic hero is given leeway and at times blindly followed.
By the way, for those who saw the latest Batman movie, the character - Harvie Dent, Gotham's crime fighting D.A. - was that charismatic hero/leader the people of Gotham were looking for.
If you are a dynammic leader, if you are loaded with charisma, (if you are nodding yes in agreement that you are these things - then you really have a problem) you have a lot of hard work to do on the issues of pride and humility, on the matter of God's glory or yours, and whether you will be surrendered and dependent or self-sufficient and self-reliant.
If you are mentoring someone who is a dynamic, charismatic leader, you must bring these issues to the front burner for discussion.
I had a conversation recently with a pretty charismatic leader. I didn't know whether to be envious of his charisma or to pity him. With charisma, there is a lurking devil in the shadow called pride.
Pride goes before destruction. Proverbs 16:18
The Lord detests all the proud. Proverbs 16:5
Whoever exalts himself will be humbled. Matthew 23:12
God opposed the proud. James 4:6
James MacGregor Burns is pretty critical of the charismatic leader.
Pure charismatic leadership also distorts constructive and mutually empowering leader-follower relationships. Followers are portrayed as so loyal or obeisant that . . . they can have little impact on the leader beyond gratifying his own psychological hungers . . .
Just as charismatic leadership fails to empower followers, so leaders are not empowered by subservient followers. . . .
At best charisma is a confusing and undemocratic form of leadership. At worst, it is a type of tyranny.
And for the follower, their danger is that they become "charisma hungry" in times of crisis, confusion and fear (Erik Erikson). That's certainly a possibility in the season ahead.
Brian Rice
p.s. It is certainly possible to be a charismatic individual who is not full of herself or himself. Just difficult to sustain over time.
p.p.s. And certainly, charismatic leaders have often used their charisma as a tool to get many good things done.