Several days ago I posted a NOTE on Facebook about Michael Vick and the public reaction to him. Wehad quite a good discussion. I thought I would do a bit of editing of that NOTE and put it on the blogsite.
**********************
I have been REALLY struck by the public reaction to Michael Vick being picked up by the Eagles. Well, some of the public reaction. It is hard to know how many people really feel this way, or is the attention just being focused on the few who do, since it makes for good news and spicy sports commentary.
Here is what strikes me. We (at least some of us) are an angry people, an unforgiving people, and a judgmental people.
I am not minimizing the crime Michael Vick committed. The dog fighting ring was not just wrong, it was a despicable evil. It deserves to be a crime. It deserves to be punished. Vick did the crime and he did the time. (Maybe he should have done more time, but that is for the court system to determine.)
Now - what and who is Michael Vick? (I'll explain this one below.)
And - how do we assess and treat Michael Vick?
What do we believe about forgiveness, grace, second chances, new beginnings, fresh starts, the possibility of redemption (or if that word is too strong) the possibility of change in those who have done wrong?
Here are a few thoughts that have been rumbling around in my mind over the last number of days as I have read the news and especially listened to the sports commentators on this issue.
ONE: What/Who is Michael Vick? Is he still a criminal, an ex-criminal, a reformed criminal, a recovering criminal, a repentant criminal ... ? We are characterizing Vick with our descriptive labels.
Is he a loser, a con, a cad, a fraud, a phony, a washed up human being? Is he dirt, scum, filth ...?
Listening to some of the angry voice out there - he is everything I just mentioned in the previous sentence.
Who is Vick in the eyes of God? Should we have the same eyes to see Vick as God does?
TWO: What do we believe about forgivenes, grace, redemption and other such things? Or maybe we no longer believe those things (or understand or experience them) in our post-Christian culture?
How does one become a truly "ex-con?"
Is it possible for one to be a "former but no longer criminal?"
Do we believe Michael Vick does not deserve forgiveness and grace and redemption?
Or let me state this just slightly different, do we believe Vick is beyond the possibility of forgiveness, grace and redemption?
Is there a list of crimes/trespasses/sins that we say, cross this line and we as a society believe you are irremediably fallen and we want nothing to do with you? If so - who came up with the list and on what basis?
Has anyone stopped to think that some of these angry critics seem an awlful lot like the "elder brother" of the Prodigal Son parable?
Fortunately for Vick, Tony Dungy has opened his arms like the "waiting father." And fortunately for Vick, Andy Reid knows something of the pain of a father who has his own prodigal son problems.
THREE: How about this for some sheer hypocrisy on our part?
If we are fallen, how do we want to be treated and received? Do we really want to be treated and labeled by others in the way the critics are doing to Vick? Do we even remember the Golden Rule any longer?
Are we really so confident that we are without sin and therefore fully qualified to be throwing the first stones at Vick? Where are the prophets who write in the sand and we the accusers walk away convicted and ashamed of our own evil?
FOUR: What do we really want for Vick? Do we want him to be endlessly punished and scorned and downgraded to a sub-person status? Does the spirit of vindictiveness sour us that much? Or do we really long for his transformation? Do we mourn over his (and our own) sin and pray for healing and transformation? Or do we gloat in how the mighty are fallen and how the evil get their just desserts (finally, it's about time)? Do we really want to live with the eye for an eye way of life?
What would love ask of us concerning Michael Vick?
Here is an interesting one mentioned earlier, repeated with a slight twist: What do you think Christ thinks of Michael Vick? What do you think Jesus wants for Vick? And why would we not want the same for him?
FIVE: And finally -what if we are wrong in giving grace? What if Vick is only playing the well orchestrated, publicity game? What if there is no change at all in him? What if he remains a really bad person? What then? What have we lost by being gracious people?
And what has happened to us when we are critical, condemning, angry, bitter, unforgiving, self-righteous, vindictive . . . ? I know what these things do to my soul. It isn't pretty.
****************
Your thoughts and observations and arguments are desired?
Brian "a recovering stone thrower" Rice
Leadership ConneXtions International
www.lci.typepad.com